top of page

Assignment Three

Assignment Three: Critical Essay

Has the ‘digital revolution’ created more problems than
opportunities for today’s professional photographers?

Balancing Act: Assessing the Impact of the Digital Revolution on Professional Photography

Introduction:

The emergence of the digital revolution in photography has undeniably transformed how professional photographers operate. This shift, characterised by the rapid evolution of digital technologies, has brought unprecedented opportunities and unforeseen challenges for photographers in the contemporary era. This essay critically examines whether the digital revolution has created more problems than opportunities for today's professional photographers, drawing insights from relevant case studies and specific aspects of modern professional photography.

Accessibility and Democratisation:

The digital revolution has democratised photography, making it accessible to a broader audience. The accessibility of high-quality cameras, combined with user-friendly editing software becoming available for everyone, has lowered the entry barriers for aspiring photographers. However, this accessibility has also led to market saturation, making it harder for professionals to distinguish themselves in an oversaturated field.

Conversely, the quest for pixel-perfect images has raised concerns about the loss of authenticity and creativity in professional photography. As photographers rely heavily on post-processing, some argue that the moment's authenticity is compromised, and the line between photography and digital art blurs. The pressure to produce flawless images can stifle creativity, as photographers may prioritise technical perfection over storytelling and emotional depth.

The capture of an image manipulates the final result in some way for electronic and chemical processes. Whether from the chemistry, electronic processing, or multiple photos stacked into one. However, the technology in mirrorless and mobile cameras has taken this to another level and made producing high-quality images more accessible than ever. 

The iPhone Revolution:

Professional photography was once considered a specialist subject, but the moniker Pro seems to be an addition to modern mobile, suggesting we are all photographers now but also professionals. This is not the case; while images produced from mobile phones are infinitely improved from year to year, they still have a long way to go to be considered truly professional.

The advent of smartphones, particularly the iPhone, has revolutionised how we capture and share moments. With each new release, Apple emphasises the enhanced camera capabilities, often dubbing them "Pro" cameras. Can the iPhone genuinely be a professional tool for photography when compared to traditional professional cameras? Exploring the features of the iPhone camera and comparing them with those of professional photography equipment, we must consider other factors such as image quality, versatility, and user experience.

Image Quality:

Professional photographers often rely on high-end DSLR or mirrorless cameras with larger sensors, allowing for greater light sensitivity and improved image quality, especially in low-light conditions. While the iPhone has made significant strides in image quality, it still needs to be enhanced due to its smaller sensor size. Professional cameras generally provide a superior dynamic range, colour accuracy, and detail retention, making them preferable for demanding photographic tasks.

Versatility:

Versatility is another essential aspect when comparing the iPhone to professional cameras. iPhones boast many features, including multiple lenses, computational photography, and advanced software algorithms. However, professional cameras offer more flexibility regarding lens options, manual controls, and the ability to use specialised equipment such as external flashes and advanced accessories. The adaptability of professional cameras to different shooting scenarios gives photographers a distinct advantage over the iPhone.

User Experience:

The iPhone excels in user experience, providing an intuitive and accessible platform for photography enthusiasts. The seamless integration of hardware and software, coupled with features like Smart HDR and Night mode, ensures that users can effortlessly capture stunning images. On the other hand, professional cameras may have a steeper learning curve, requiring users to master manual controls and settings for optimal results. 

Pro or not Pro?

Professional photographers continue to rely on dedicated camera systems, with their specific demands for image quality, versatility, and control. The iPhone's strengths lie in its accessibility, ease of use, and the convenience of always having a capable camera. Ultimately, whether the iPhone can be considered a "pro" camera depends on the photographer's context and specific needs. It serves as a valuable tool for everyday photography but may only partially replace the professional camera in the hands of a seasoned photographer tackling more demanding situations.

Instagram, a photo-sharing platform, has empowered a new generation of photographers to reach global audiences. Influencers like Brandon Woelfel and Murad Osmann have built lucrative careers by leveraging the platform's features to showcase their unique visual style.

Case Study: Instagram Influencers and Content Creation
Brandon Woelfel Bio:

Brandon Woelfel attended The School of Visual Arts in Manhattan to study 2D and 3D animation computer art. During this time, he became interested in photography and started shooting images using friends as models.
His audience of 2.8 million Instagram followers resulted from hard work, learning his target audience, and the following big style.
Consistency was the key here as he quickly learned how Instagram works and how to capitalise on the market.
He has produced several books and has a studio in New York with high-profile clients such as Apple, Urban Outfitters, and Nikon cameras. 

FullSizeRender+180.jpg
FullSizeRender+121.jpg

Fig 1 Image Credit - Brandon Woelfel

Fig 2 Image Credit - Brandon Woelfel

Murad Osmann Bio:

Murad Osmann was born in Dagestan, Russia, before moving to Moscow early, then 11 years old in England in 2001. 
While studying civil engineering there, he started to become interested in photography. 

He says, "Photography is about capturing things other people might miss. It is a way to communicate and bring images I hold to the surface."

He is known for his travel photography series 'Follow Me', which happened accidentally when his girlfriend and now wife Natalia Zakharova used to pull him away from taking too many photos on holiday. His Instagram account has over 4.1 million followers, but the interesting fact is he used an iPhone at the beginning of his account but now uses a DSLR for a wider field of view. 

MuradBali.jpg
MuradVenice.jpg

Fig 3 Image Credit - Murad Osmaan

Fig 4 Image Credit - Murad Osmaan

Impact on Traditional Photography Business Models Monetisation and Commercial Viability

The digital revolution has disrupted traditional business models in the photography industry. Print sales have declined, and the demand for physical portfolios has shifted towards online and social media presence. Additionally, the rise of freelancing and gig economy platforms has altered the employment landscape for photographers. While this shift has fostered opportunities for new income streams, it has also introduced instability. 

Platforms like Shutterstock and Getty Images allow photographers to sell their images globally once a lucrative source of income is affected by free or low-cost image-sharing platforms, e.g. Unsplash and Wirestock. 

Many photographers now rely on licensing agreements, fine art prints, or commissions to generate revenue. The democratisation of photography has also led to oversaturation in the market. With millions of images uploaded daily, standing out amidst the noise has become a significant challenge for professional photographers. Copyright infringement remains a persistent issue, with many images used without proper attribution or compensation. 

Real life Case Study: The client is always right, or are they?

A well-established photographer told me about their experience when quoting for a booking—a professional for several years against novice photographers with excellent computer skills. The professional has a fantastic portfolio; the novice produced perfect images. The novice used every available software to add multiple elements. The client chose the novice on the strength of the portfolio.

The scenario asks if the professional adapts to suit today's demand or stays as they are and loses more professional bookings. There's no right or wrong answer, but if professional photographers want to sustain a realistic livelihood, it makes sense to adapt to modern trends.

Adaptation and Skill Diversification

The digital revolution has necessitated a rapid evolution of skills for professional photographers. Beyond capturing a moment, photographers need post-processing, digital marketing, and social media management proficiency. While this diversification of skills has expanded the scope of opportunities, it has also placed additional demands on professionals, potentially diverting their focus from the core craft of photography.

Ethical Considerations, Copyright Infringement and Manipulation

The ease of digital manipulation has brought forth ethical concerns within professional photography. The ability to alter reality has led to debates surrounding authenticity, credibility, and the potential to misrepresent events or subjects. 

The increased image quality and creative control enabled by digital technology allow photographers to produce stunning visuals. However, this technological shift has also led to concerns about authenticity and creativity.
Many software packages exist, for example, Topaz Labs, Luminar AI and Photoshop (Content aware), which can sharpen images, replace skies or eliminate objects and people from the original photo. The difference between original and manipulated to the finished product is becoming more complicated. Striking a balance between artistic expression and moral integrity has become a pressing concern in the digital age.

Copyright Infringement, Intellectual Property and Piracy:

The ease of digital reproduction and sharing has led to rampant copyright infringement in the professional photography industry and unauthorised use of images. Images can be easily copied, distributed, and used without proper attribution or compensation, posing a significant problem for photographers, who rely on copyright protection to safeguard their work and livelihood.
Additionally, the rise of user-generated content on social media platforms has blurred the line between professional and amateur photography.

Case Study: Richard Prince
1681727836-richard-prince-artist-04.avif

Fig 5 Image Credit - Richard Prince

The case of Richard Prince, an artist who appropriated and sold other photographers' Instagram images without permission, exemplifies the ongoing struggle for artists to protect their work in the digital realm. 

In May 2023, two professional photographers won a decision against copyright infringements to their original work used by Prince. A US Federal judge ruled that "Prince did not provide enough initial evidence to prove that his "New Portraits" series sufficiently transformed two of the photographs he appropriated.

Case Study: East vs. West AI produced images debate

China: November 2023:  A court ruling in China regarding the copyright protection of AI-generated images acknowledged the need to protect their intellectual property rights. This decision establishes a framework for attributing ownership and authorship of AI-generated content, offering legal clarity in a rapidly evolving technological landscape. The ruling emphasises the importance of safeguarding the rights of individuals and organisations investing in AI innovation. This legal development contributes to establishing a robust intellectual property framework and fosters a conducive environment for continued advancements in artificial intelligence technology within the Chinese legal landscape.

Europe and America:  The decision underscores the necessity to adapt traditional copyright frameworks to address the unique challenges posed by artificial intelligence. The ruling seeks to balance the rights of AI developers and original content creators while acknowledging novel, algorithmic-based artistic contributions. This pivotal moment shapes copyright law for the digital age, as jurisdictions on both sides of the Atlantic strive to establish a coherent and forward-thinking legal framework for protecting the intellectual property associated with AI-generated images.

Conclusion: The Digital Revolution and AI

In conclusion, the digital revolution has undeniably brought opportunities and challenges for today's professional photographers. Accessibility and competition have made it easier for newcomers to enter the field but have also resulted in market saturation and intense pricing competition. The accessibility and democratisation of photography have expanded the pool of talent, fostering inclusivity and creativity. 

Content creators like Brandon Woelfel and Murad Osmann have established a livelihood from capturing the market. However, like Instagram, this is short-lived. Many photographers who decide to become content creators have fallen by the wayside, needing awareness of the clientele and consistency to sustain market success.
Evolving business models have opened up new revenue streams but created financial instability. Market saturation, commodification, ethical considerations, and the need for diversified skill sets have introduced complexities that demand careful navigation.

The digital environment has posed a significant challenge to copyright protection and intellectual property, affecting the rights and livelihoods of professional photographers. Richard Prince's court case is an exciting conclusion as the US Federal judge favoured the original photographers. Prince was earning up to $100,000 at the expense of others' work. Would those photographers be able to sell their work for a similar price? Where do we draw the line between when appropriation is appropriate? Mischa Henner is an artist I admire, but the basis of his work is the appropriation of imagery available online.

Ultimately, the digital revolution's impact on professional photography is of empowerment and constraint, requiring photographers to adapt, innovate, and reflect on the evolving nature of their craft in the digital age.

Finally, integrating artificial intelligence (AI) into art, design, and photography is poised to have a transformative impact on how professionals in these creative domains approach their work. AI tools and algorithms can streamline and enhance various aspects of the creative process, offering artists, designers, and photographers new tools to explore and expand their creative boundaries. For instance, AI-driven software can assist in automating repetitive tasks, allowing professionals to focus more on their work's conceptual and innovative aspects. Additionally, AI can analyse vast amounts of data to provide insights into trends and audience preferences, helping artists tailor their creations to better resonate with their target audiences.

However, the incorporation of AI also raises questions about the role of human creativity and the potential for overreliance on automated tools. Striking the right balance will be crucial for maintaining the authenticity and personal touch that define the work of professional artists, designers, and photographers. As technology continues to evolve, successful professionals in these fields will likely leverage AI as a complementary tool to augment their creative capabilities rather than replace the uniquely human aspects of artistic expression.

References:

28 Years Later: Danny Boyle’s New Zombie Flick Was Shot on an iPhone 15 | WIRED [WWW Document], n.d. URL https://www.wired.com/story/28-years-later-danny-boyles-new-zombie-flick-was-shot-on-an-iphone-15/ (accessed 1.17.25).

AI and journalism: What’s next? | Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism [WWW Document], n.d. URL https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/news/ai-and-journalism-whats-next (accessed 1.17.25).

An Instagram feed you have to follow: @muradosmann [WWW Document], n.d. . DPReview. URL https://www.dpreview.com/articles/1649742150/instagram-you-must-follow-muradosmann (accessed 1.17.25).

Article, S.C.S.T., 2023. A Judge Has Greenlit Two Lawsuits Against Appropriation Artist Richard Prince From Photographers Who Say He Stole Their Work [WWW Document]. Artnet News. URL https://news.artnet.com/art-world/richard-prince-instagram-fair-use-lawsuit-to-proceed-2301826 (accessed 1.17.25).

Beijing court’s ruling that AI-generated content can be covered by copyright eschews US stand, with far-reaching implications on tech’s use | South China Morning Post [WWW Document], n.d. URL https://www.scmp.com/tech/tech-trends/article/3243570/beijing-courts-ruling-ai-generated-content-can-be-covered-copyright-eschews-us-stand-far-reaching (accessed 12.3.23).

Brandon Woelfel [WWW Document], n.d. . Brandon Woelfel. URL https://www.brandonwoelfel.com (accessed 12.3.23).

Chinese Court’s Landmark Ruling: AI Images Can be Copyrighted [WWW Document], n.d. URL https://aibusiness.com/nlp/chinese-court-s-landmark-ruling-ai-images-can-be-copyrighted (accessed 12.3.23).

Early Photographic Appropriation [WWW Document], n.d. . The Guggenheim Museums and Foundation. URL https://www.guggenheim.org/teaching-materials/richard-prince-spiritual-america/early-photographic-appropriation (accessed 12.3.23).

Getty Images acquires Shutterstock in $3.7 billion deal to dominate stock media [WWW Document], n.d. . EMARKETER. URL https://www.emarketer.com/content/getty-images-acquires-shutterstock--3-7-billion-deal-dominate-stock-media (accessed 1.17.25).

Getty Images and Shutterstock announce merger in $3.7b deal - Australian Photography [WWW Document], n.d. URL https://www.australianphotography.com/news/getty-images-and-shutterstock-announce-merger-in-3-7b-deal (accessed 1.17.25).

Getty Images and Shutterstock to Merge, Creating a Premier Visual Content Company - Getty Images [WWW Document], n.d. URL https://investors.gettyimages.com/news-releases/news-release-details/getty-images-and-shutterstock-merge-creating-premier-visual/ (accessed 1.17.25).

Is ChatGPT a threat or an opportunity for journalism? Five AI experts weigh in | Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism [WWW Document], n.d. URL https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/news/chatgpt-threat-or-opportunity-journalism-five-ai-experts-weigh (accessed 1.17.25).

Jobs’ Legacy: First Use Of iPhone For TV News - CBS Miami [WWW Document], 2011. URL https://www.cbsnews.com/miami/news/jobs-legacy-first-use-of-iphone-for-tv-news/ (accessed 1.17.25).

Murad Osmann – Capture Your Stories. [WWW Document], n.d. URL https://muradosmann.com/ (accessed 12.3.23).

MURAD OSMANN (@muradosmann) • Instagram photos and videos [WWW Document], n.d. URL https://www.instagram.com/muradosmann/ (accessed 12.3.23).

New iPhone photography exhibition debuts in Paris on November 10 [WWW Document], n.d. . Apple Newsroom (Malta). URL https://www.apple.com/mt/newsroom/2023/11/new-iphone-photography-exhibition-debuts-in-paris-on-november-10/ (accessed 1.17.25).

PERSONAL PROJECTS [WWW Document], n.d. . ERIK JOHANSSON. URL https://www.erikjo.com/work (accessed 12.3.23).

Richard Prince: The Controversial Artist and Master of Appropriation [WWW Document], 2016. . Highsnobiety. URL https://www.highsnobiety.com/p/richard-prince-artist/ (accessed 12.3.23).

Stock Images, Photos, Vectors, Video, and Music [WWW Document], n.d. . Shutterstock. URL https://www.shutterstock.com/ (accessed 1.17.25).

Toor, A., 2013. Chicago Sun-Times trains reporters to shoot with iPhones after laying off all its photographers [WWW Document]. The Verge. URL https://www.theverge.com/2013/6/1/4386074/chicago-sun-times-cuts-entire-photography-staff-trains-reporters-iphone (accessed 1.17.25).

Will AI-generated images create a new crisis for fact-checkers? Experts are not so sure | Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism [WWW Document], n.d. URL https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/news/will-ai-generated-images-create-new-crisis-fact-checkers-experts-are-not-so-sure (accessed 1.17.25).

Images:

Assignment Three: Tutor Feedback 

oca-logo.webp
bottom of page